Publisher DOI: 10.1080/13669877.2022.2108120
Title: The effectiveness of risk assessments in risk workshops: the role of calculative cultures
Language: English
Authors: Bellora-Bienengräber, Lucia 
Harten, Clemens 
Meyer, Matthias 
Keywords: agent-based modeling; Calculative culture; ECHO network; enterprise risk management; risk assessment; risk workshop
Issue Date: 2022
Source: Journal of Risk Research (in Press): (2022)
Abstract (english): 
This paper investigates drivers of the effectiveness of risk assessments in risk workshops dominated by ‘quantitative skepticism’. Moreover, it contrasts our findings with those of previous research that assumed the dominance of ‘quantitative enthusiasm’. Quantitative skepticism is a calculative culture characterized by an attitude that regards risk assessments as learning tools supporting the holistic formation of judgments incorporating difficult-to-quantify information. It contrasts with quantitative enthusiasm, which is a calculative culture that considers risk assessments as fully descriptive of reality. Prior research primarily focused on understanding the effectiveness of risk assessments under a calculative culture of quantitative enthusiasm. To understand what drives the correctness of risk assessment and the time needed to assess risks in workshops under a calculative culture of quantitative skepticism, we use an agent-based model that simulates risk assessment with risk workshops and that models agents’ cognitive processes using ECHO, a constraint satisfaction network (CSN). Our simulations show that, compared to risk workshops under conditions of quantitative enthusiasm, there are often lengthy periods of stagnation in individual and collective risk assessments and a strong path dependency on discussions. Prioritizing concerned participants improves the correct assessment of high risks at the expense of the correct assessment of low risks. Notwithstanding similarities in the drivers of the effectiveness of risk assessment across different calculative cultures, our results show that the predominant calculative culture matters when—to enhance their effectiveness—designing and implementing risk workshops.
ISSN: 1366-9877
Journal: Journal of risk research 
Institute: Controlling und Simulation W-1 
Document Type: Article
Appears in Collections:Publications without fulltext

Show full item record

Page view(s)

checked on Feb 7, 2023

Google ScholarTM


Add Files to Item

Note about this record

Cite this record


Items in TORE are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.